Employer National Insurance Contributions (ERNICs)
One of the most prominent recommendations in the Milburn Review is doubling the threshold at which employers pay ERNICs from £5,000 to £10,000 for 21-24-year-olds in the retail and hospitality sectors. Back in the 2024 Autumn Budget, then-Chancellor Rachel Reeves lowered this threshold from £9,000 to £5,000 and increased the tax rate, thereby raising the cost of employment.
This had a profound impact on the costs faced by the beauty industry and the British Beauty Council has consistently called for a return to the 2024 settlement. The Council, therefore, warmly welcomes this recommendation. The inclusion of retail alongside hospitality is highly promising, as last year retail lost the most jobs among beauty sub-sectors, according to ‘Value of Beauty’, dropping from 117,159 to 109,453 – a fall of 6.6%.
National Minimum Wage (NMW)
Continuing the topic of employment costs, the Milburn Review cautioned against continuing Labour’s policy of convergence between the National Minimum Wage and the National Living Wage. The rationale behind this policy is ending discrimination against young workers and seeing them better paid. However, a persistent concern for the industry has been that the costs of employing young people has gone up rapidly, making it unfeasible to sustain young hiring.
The British Beauty Council welcomes this recommendation, as it is in line with the Council’s submission to the Low Pay Commission earlier this year, where it recommended only merging the National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage if youth employment levels remain strong. Ministers appear to be taking a cautious approach, both rates rose by an identical 3.9% in the Autumn Budget rather than closing the gap, and Cabinet Office Minister Pat McFadden recently confirmed that youth job figures are already being factored into pay decisions.
Apprenticeships
The Milburn Review included a number of recommendations that could result in notable changes to the apprenticeships system. These included:
- Simplifying the process of finding apprenticeships, based on the UCAS model for university courses
- Expanding short courses for over-25s
- Increasing the employer hiring payment for apprentices aged 16–24 from £2,000 to £2,500 and extending it to levy-paying employers
- Prioritising expansion of Levels 2 and 3, which have experienced particularly steep declines in apprenticeship starts
- Introducing an initial 25,000 places to help young people prepare for apprenticeships through technical training, work-readiness support and employer experience
- Removing the requirement to pass Level 2 English and maths examinations as a condition of completing an apprenticeship, while retaining the requirement to continue studying them
Restructuring apprenticeship funding
A potentially concerning recommendation for hair and beauty is the restructuring of apprenticeship funding. The Milburn Review recommends fully funding eligible apprenticeships for under-25s regardless of employer size, while reducing government funding for apprentices aged 25 and over by 25%, with a potential further reduction by 2031/32.
This measure would increase the cost of providing apprenticeships to adults, discouraging smaller salons from taking on older trainees. Hair and beauty provide opportunities for adults changing careers, as well as younger people entering employment for the first time.
However, the full effects of such a policy on the industry are hard to predict. The British beauty workforce is overwhelmingly young, with 49% of the workforce younger than 35. Depending on the nature of demand, restructuring government apprenticeship funding could see an uptick in apprenticeship rates in the industry.
Other recommendations notable for beauty employers
Most significant was extending the Youth Jobs Grant, meaning companies would get £3,000 for hiring a young person who has been NEET for over six months irrespective of whether that person was receiving benefits. There would be an additional £2,000 for businesses employing fewer than 50 people. A further £2,000 would be available for recruiting young people facing additional barriers to employment.
The report also suggested delaying the extension of automatic pension enrolment to 18-year-olds, and the removal of the lower earnings limit for under-25s, until at least 2031.
What happens next?
The Government will now consider the report’s recommendations alongside the soon to be published Timms Review before setting out a full response to both reports in a White Paper next year.
In the meantime, the Government has set out what it says are “immediate steps to start delivering this new settlement for young people”. This includes:
- A new locally led youth service to better connect young people with employment, health, skills and wider youth support.
- A new Opportunity and Support Guarantee for young people to ensure every young person will have a real opportunity to gain a college place, training, an apprenticeship, high-quality work experience or a job.
- A new Youth Opportunities Unit chaired by Alan Milburn, the report’s author, which will report directly to the Prime Minister and make youth opportunity a priority across government.
- A ‘Jobs Guarantee’ available to young people who have been out of work or education for 12 months. As part of the scheme, the Department will fully fund employers to offer six months of paid work at 25 hours a week, covering 100% of wage costs including associated employer NICs and pension contributions, and up to £250 per young person for onboarding. Young people on the scheme will also receive Department for Work & Pensions funded support.
Further details on these measures is expected to follow in the coming weeks.
Speaking about the report and its recommendations, Millie Kendall OBE, CEO of the British Beauty Council commented:
“The beauty industry is a powerhouse for youth employment, with nearly half of our workforce under the age of 35, so we warmly welcome the Milburn Review’s focus on breaking down barriers for young people entering work.
“Rapidly rising employment costs have hit our sector hard, which resulted in significant job losses last year. Recommendations to double the Employer NICs threshold for 21 to 24-year-olds for retail and hospitality, alongside a measured approach to National Minimum Wage that protects youth job outcomes, are pragmatic steps that mirror what the British Beauty Council has long called for.
“While we are encouraged by increased hiring incentives for young apprentices and renewed support for Levels 2 and 3, we do urge caution over reducing apprenticeship funding for those aged 25 and over. Hair and beauty offer vital pathways for adult career-changers, and we must ensure businesses aren’t priced out of training older talent. We look forward to working closely with the Government and the new Youth Opportunities Unit ahead of next year’s White Paper to ensure these proposals deliver real, lasting opportunities across British high streets.”